June 22, 2024
Car Repair

American drivers continue to struggle with high car insurance rates

Driving down the highway has long been considered a quintessential American activity, but it has also become increasingly costly.

The expenses associated with owning and maintaining a car have surged in the wake of the pandemic. While some aspects of car ownership have become more affordable, others have become budget-busters.

One of the latest financial burdens for drivers is the spike in auto insurance costs, which have risen by 20.6% compared to last year as of February. This marks the largest increase in car insurance costs based on government data dating back to 1985. It also represents the most significant price hike for February within the 28 categories monitored by Yahoo Finance since 2021.

Although car insurance may not receive as much attention as other essential expenses like food, gas, and rent, it is a significant contributor to the current persistently high inflation rate.

Car insurance constitutes 2.5% of the goods and services basket used in calculating the overall inflation rate. It is also included in the “core” inflation metric, excluding food and energy, closely monitored by the Federal Reserve. Core inflation rose by 0.4% from the previous month in February and by 3.8% from the previous year.

The average monthly cost of insurance for car owners is now $212, equivalent to $2,545 per year, according to Bankrate.

For those financing their vehicle, the typical monthly payment ranges from about $530 for a used car to $740 for a new model. Insurance adds 25%-40% to the monthly cost of car ownership, an expense that some buyers may overlook when budgeting for a purchase.

Another factor contributing to the high inflation rate is the escalating cost of housing, with shelter expenses rising by 5.7% year over year, comprising a significant portion of core inflation growth over the past year.

While certain essential items like groceries have seen modest price increases of just 1% year over year, other goods such as appliances, electronics, and toys have become more affordable.

Multiple Factors at Play

The surge in insurance premiums cannot be attributed to a single cause, as various factors are influencing the spike in rates.

Supply chain disruptions stemming from the pandemic have led to a shortage of new vehicles, driving up prices and subsequently increasing repair costs. The complexity of modern cars, equipped with advanced electronics and systems, has also contributed to higher repair expenses.

Moreover, there is evidence to suggest that drivers are engaging in faster driving behaviors, resulting in more severe accidents and heightened insurance costs.

These challenges in the automotive industry come on the heels of a significant increase in car prices, altering the affordability landscape for many consumers.

In 2022, the year-over-year price hike for new cars reached 13%, while used car inflation exceeded 40%. Semiconductor shortages and supply chain disruptions severely impacted new car production in 2021 and 2022, prompting a surge in the used car market and unprecedented inflation rates.

Although car prices have stabilized following supply chain improvements, they remain substantially higher than pre-pandemic levels, with new car prices up by 21% and used car prices up by 31% compared to four years ago.

According to Kelley Blue Book, the average cost of a new car now stands at $47,401, though recent data from J.D. Power indicates a $4,700 decline in average transaction prices last month. The typical used car is priced at nearly $26,000.

Fueling up a vehicle is also becoming costlier, with gasoline prices currently around $3.40 per gallon, marking a 32% increase from prices four years ago.

Despite these challenges, there are some positive developments on the horizon for patient buyers. The surplus of electric vehicles has triggered significant price drops for certain models, including Teslas. Gas prices in 2024 may exhibit a slight decrease compared to 2023, and transaction prices, while still elevated, have shown a decline in recent months as automakers ramp up production levels.

Rick Newman, a senior columnist for Yahoo Finance, can be followed on Twitter at @rickjnewman.

Explore political news on business and economic policies influencing future stock prices.

Stay updated on the latest financial and business news from Yahoo Finance.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why have car insurance costs increased significantly?

The rise in car insurance premiums can be attributed to factors such as supply chain disruptions, higher repair costs for modern vehicles, and increased crash severity due to faster driving behaviors.

Are there any positive developments in the automotive industry for consumers?

Buyers can expect price drops for electric vehicles, potential decreases in gas prices for 2024, and a gradual decline in transaction prices as automakers normalize production levels.


The current landscape of the automotive industry reflects a complex interplay of factors leading to heightened costs for consumers. Understanding the drivers behind these cost increases can empower individuals to make informed decisions regarding car ownership and financial planning.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *